Email security solutions safeguard organizations from malicious attacks delivered via email. These solutions analyze incoming and outgoing messages, identifying and neutralizing threats such as phishing, malware, spam, and impersonation attempts. For example, a sophisticated system might detect a phishing email by analyzing the sender’s address, links within the message, and the message’s content, preventing it from reaching employee inboxes.
Protecting against email-borne threats is crucial for maintaining business continuity and safeguarding sensitive data. Such protection mitigates the risk of financial loss, reputational damage, and legal repercussions associated with data breaches. Historically, email security has evolved from basic spam filters to advanced systems utilizing artificial intelligence and machine learning to combat increasingly sophisticated attacks.
The following sections will delve into the core components of a robust email security strategy, including advanced threat detection techniques, data loss prevention measures, and best practices for user awareness training.
1. URL Protection
URL protection forms a critical line of defense within a comprehensive email security strategy. Many targeted attacks leverage malicious URLs embedded within emails. These URLs may direct recipients to fraudulent websites designed to steal credentials, download malware, or perform other malicious actions. Effective URL protection analyzes links in real-time, comparing them against known threat databases and using heuristic analysis to identify potentially harmful patterns. This proactive approach prevents users from inadvertently accessing dangerous websites, even if the email itself bypasses other security filters. For instance, a phishing email might mimic a legitimate banking site, attempting to trick users into entering their login details. Robust URL protection would identify the fraudulent link and prevent access, protecting users from credential theft.
The importance of URL protection is amplified by the increasing sophistication of phishing techniques. Attackers often employ URL shortening services or obfuscation techniques to conceal malicious intent. Advanced URL protection systems counter these tactics by analyzing the underlying destination of the link, regardless of its superficial appearance. This deep inspection is crucial for identifying and neutralizing evolving threats. For example, a URL might appear innocuous at first glance, but redirect users through a series of intermediary sites before landing on a malicious destination. Advanced URL protection systems can unravel these complex redirect chains and block access to the ultimate threat.
In conclusion, robust URL protection is an indispensable component of effective email security. By proactively analyzing links and blocking access to malicious websites, organizations can significantly reduce the risk of successful targeted attacks. This layer of defense, combined with other security measures, provides a comprehensive shield against the evolving threat landscape, protecting sensitive data and maintaining business continuity. The ongoing development of more sophisticated URL analysis techniques, incorporating machine learning and artificial intelligence, promises even greater protection against future threats.
2. Attachment Analysis
Attachment analysis plays a vital role in mitigating targeted email threats. Malicious attachments represent a primary vector for delivering malware, ransomware, and other harmful payloads. A robust attachment analysis system dissects incoming email attachments, employing various techniques to identify potential threats. These techniques include signature-based detection, which compares file characteristics against a known malware database; sandboxing, which executes attachments in a controlled environment to observe their behavior; and static and dynamic analysis, which examine the code structure and execution flow of files to identify malicious intent. For instance, a seemingly innocuous document might contain embedded macros designed to download and execute malware upon opening. Effective attachment analysis can detect and neutralize such threats before they compromise systems.
The importance of attachment analysis is amplified by the evolving tactics of threat actors. Attackers frequently employ sophisticated techniques to evade detection, such as using polymorphic malware that changes its signature to avoid detection by traditional antivirus software, or embedding malicious code within seemingly benign file types like PDFs or Microsoft Office documents. Advanced attachment analysis solutions utilize machine learning and other advanced techniques to identify these sophisticated threats. For example, a machine learning model might identify unusual patterns in a file’s structure or behavior, even if it doesn’t match any known malware signatures. This proactive approach is crucial for detecting zero-day exploits and other emerging threats.
In summary, robust attachment analysis is an essential component of a comprehensive email security strategy. By scrutinizing email attachments for malicious content, organizations can significantly reduce the risk of malware infections and other security breaches. Effective attachment analysis, combined with other security measures like URL protection and impersonation detection, provides a multi-layered defense against targeted email threats. Continued advancements in attachment analysis techniques, including the integration of artificial intelligence and behavioral analysis, will further enhance the ability to identify and neutralize evolving threats.
3. Impersonation Detection
Impersonation detection serves as a critical defense against sophisticated phishing and business email compromise (BEC) attacks, forming a crucial component of robust email security. These attacks often leverage social engineering tactics, masquerading as trusted individuals or organizations to deceive recipients into divulging sensitive information, transferring funds, or performing other harmful actions. Impersonation attempts can range from simple spoofing of display names to highly sophisticated techniques mimicking legitimate email addresses and communication styles. Effective impersonation detection analyzes various email attributes, including sender address, domain reputation, message content, and communication patterns, to identify and flag potentially fraudulent messages. For example, an email appearing to originate from a company executive, but sent from an unfamiliar domain or containing unusual requests, would raise red flags and be subject to further scrutiny. Identifying and neutralizing these threats prevents significant financial and reputational damage. Impersonation protection must analyze both internal and external communications. Internal email impersonation, where attackers compromise employee accounts to target colleagues, poses a considerable threat. External impersonation targets customers, partners, or other external stakeholders, potentially damaging relationships and trust.
The increasing sophistication of impersonation attacks necessitates advanced detection techniques. Attackers often exploit subtle variations in email addresses or use compromised legitimate accounts, making detection more challenging. Modern impersonation detection leverages machine learning algorithms and artificial intelligence to analyze vast datasets of email communications, identifying subtle anomalies indicative of impersonation attempts. For instance, an algorithm might detect a slight deviation in the typical writing style of an executive, raising suspicion even if the email address appears legitimate. This proactive approach is crucial for identifying and neutralizing sophisticated impersonation attempts that might bypass traditional security filters. Additionally, integration with threat intelligence feeds provides real-time updates on known impersonation tactics and malicious actors, further enhancing detection capabilities.
In conclusion, robust impersonation detection is indispensable for mitigating targeted email threats. By analyzing email communications for signs of impersonation, organizations can protect themselves from financial loss, reputational damage, and the compromise of sensitive data. The integration of advanced technologies like machine learning and threat intelligence plays a vital role in combating the evolving sophistication of impersonation attacks. Ongoing development and refinement of these technologies will further strengthen email security postures against future threats.
4. Data Loss Prevention
Data loss prevention (DLP) forms an integral part of targeted threat protection within email security systems. DLP focuses on preventing sensitive data, such as financial records, intellectual property, or personally identifiable information (PII), from leaving the organization’s control via email. This protection is crucial in mitigating the risks associated with data breaches, regulatory non-compliance, and reputational damage. DLP complements other security measures by focusing specifically on the content of emails, ensuring sensitive information is not inadvertently or maliciously transmitted.
-
Content Inspection and Analysis
DLP systems inspect outgoing emails and attachments for specific data patterns, keywords, and regular expressions indicative of sensitive information. This content analysis can identify and block emails containing credit card numbers, social security numbers, confidential project details, or other sensitive data. For example, an employee attempting to send a spreadsheet containing customer PII to a personal email address would be flagged and blocked by the DLP system. Content inspection operates based on predefined policies and rules tailored to the organization’s specific data protection requirements.
-
Contextual Analysis and Policy Enforcement
DLP goes beyond simple keyword matching by incorporating contextual analysis. It considers factors such as the recipient’s email address, the sender’s department, and the communication history to determine the appropriateness of data transmission. This contextual awareness helps prevent false positives and allows for more granular policy enforcement. For example, an email containing financial data sent between members of the finance department might be permissible, while the same email sent to an external address would be blocked. Contextual analysis enables DLP to adapt to the specific communication patterns within the organization.
-
Remediation and Incident Response
When a DLP policy violation occurs, the system initiates predefined remediation actions. These actions can include blocking the email, quarantining it for review, notifying the sender and/or designated security personnel, or encrypting the message before delivery. This immediate response helps prevent data exfiltration and facilitates prompt investigation and remediation of potential security incidents. Automated remediation workflows streamline the incident response process and ensure consistent application of security policies.
-
Integration with other security measures
DLP integrates seamlessly with other email security components, such as anti-malware scanning and impersonation detection, to provide a comprehensive defense against targeted threats. For example, if an email containing sensitive data is also identified as a phishing attempt, the DLP system can prioritize its response and escalate the incident to the appropriate security team. This integrated approach strengthens the overall security posture and reduces the risk of successful data breaches. The synergy between DLP and other security measures provides a more robust defense against complex threats.
In conclusion, DLP serves as a critical component of targeted threat protection by preventing the unauthorized exfiltration of sensitive data via email. Its integration with other security measures, along with its ability to analyze content in context and enforce granular policies, makes it a powerful tool in mitigating the risks associated with data breaches and ensuring regulatory compliance. DLP is not simply a standalone feature, but a vital element of a holistic security strategy, enabling organizations to protect their valuable information assets and maintain trust with their customers and partners.
5. Adaptive Security Policies
Adaptive security policies play a crucial role in enhancing email security against targeted threats. Unlike static rules, adaptive policies dynamically adjust to the evolving threat landscape, providing a more responsive and effective defense. This adaptability is essential for countering sophisticated attacks that constantly morph and evade traditional security measures. By continuously analyzing email traffic and incorporating threat intelligence, adaptive policies enable organizations to maintain a robust security posture against emerging threats.
-
Real-time Threat Intelligence Integration
Adaptive security policies leverage real-time threat intelligence feeds to stay informed about the latest attack vectors, malware signatures, and phishing campaigns. This up-to-the-minute information enables the system to dynamically adjust security measures based on current threats. For example, if a new phishing campaign targeting a specific industry is detected, the adaptive policies can automatically enhance scrutiny of emails containing related keywords or originating from suspicious IP addresses. This proactive approach allows organizations to stay ahead of emerging threats and prevent successful attacks.
-
Behavioral Analysis and Anomaly Detection
Adaptive policies incorporate behavioral analysis to identify unusual email communication patterns that may indicate malicious activity. By establishing baselines for normal communication within the organization, the system can detect deviations that suggest compromised accounts or insider threats. For instance, an employee suddenly sending emails containing sensitive data to external recipients outside of normal business hours would trigger an alert. This anomaly detection capability enables early identification of potentially malicious behavior and prevents data breaches.
-
Automated Policy Adjustments
Adaptive policies automatically adjust security measures based on real-time threat assessments and behavioral analysis. This dynamic adjustment eliminates the need for manual intervention, allowing for a faster and more efficient response to evolving threats. For example, if a sudden surge in spam emails from a particular geographic region is detected, the system can automatically adjust spam filters to block messages originating from that region. This automated response ensures continuous protection against emerging threats without requiring manual intervention.
-
Contextual Awareness and Granular Control
Adaptive policies utilize contextual information, such as sender reputation, recipient role, and message content, to enforce granular security controls. This contextual awareness allows for more precise and effective threat detection and response. For example, an email containing financial data sent from the CFO to an external auditor might be considered legitimate, while the same email sent from a junior employee to an unknown external address would trigger a security alert. This nuanced approach minimizes false positives and ensures that legitimate business communications are not disrupted.
In conclusion, adaptive security policies significantly enhance targeted threat protection by providing a dynamic and responsive defense against evolving email threats. The ability to incorporate real-time threat intelligence, analyze communication patterns, automatically adjust security measures, and enforce granular controls based on context makes adaptive policies essential for maintaining a robust email security posture in today’s complex threat landscape. By continuously adapting to emerging threats, these policies provide organizations with the agility and resilience necessary to protect their sensitive data and maintain business continuity.
6. Automated Threat Remediation
Automated threat remediation is a crucial component of targeted threat protection within email security systems. It enables organizations to respond rapidly and effectively to identified threats, minimizing the potential for damage and reducing the burden on security teams. By automating the response process, organizations can neutralize threats quickly, even outside of business hours, limiting the impact of malware, phishing attacks, and other malicious email activity. This automation is essential for maintaining a robust security posture in the face of increasingly sophisticated and frequent attacks.
-
Real-Time Response
Automated remediation enables immediate action against identified threats, significantly reducing the window of opportunity for attackers to exploit vulnerabilities. For example, a phishing email detected by the system can be automatically quarantined or deleted before reaching the intended recipient’s inbox, preventing potential credential theft or malware infection. This real-time response is critical for containing threats quickly and minimizing their impact.
-
Consistent Enforcement of Security Policies
Automated remediation ensures consistent application of security policies across the organization. By automating the response to identified threats, organizations eliminate the potential for human error or inconsistencies in manual remediation processes. This consistent enforcement strengthens the overall security posture and reduces the risk of successful attacks. For instance, all emails containing specific keywords indicative of a phishing campaign can be automatically blocked, regardless of the sender or recipient, ensuring uniform protection across the organization. This consistency is crucial for maintaining a robust security posture and preventing targeted attacks from slipping through the cracks.
-
Reduced Burden on Security Teams
Automating the remediation process frees up valuable time and resources for security teams, allowing them to focus on more strategic security initiatives. Rather than manually investigating and responding to every individual threat, security personnel can focus on threat hunting, vulnerability management, and security awareness training. This improved efficiency optimizes resource allocation and strengthens the overall security posture. For example, automatically quarantining suspicious attachments eliminates the need for security analysts to manually analyze each file, allowing them to focus on investigating more complex threats.
-
Scalability and Adaptability
Automated remediation solutions are highly scalable and adaptable, enabling organizations to respond effectively to a large volume of threats and adapt to evolving attack vectors. As the threat landscape changes, automated remediation processes can be adjusted to address new threats and maintain a robust security posture. This flexibility and scalability is essential for protecting organizations against the ever-increasing volume and sophistication of email-borne threats. For instance, as new malware variants emerge, automated remediation systems can be updated to automatically detect and neutralize these threats, ensuring continuous protection without requiring manual intervention.
In conclusion, automated threat remediation is an essential component of targeted threat protection within a comprehensive email security strategy. By enabling rapid response, consistent policy enforcement, reduced workload on security teams, and adaptable scalability, automated remediation significantly strengthens an organization’s ability to defend against targeted email threats and maintain a strong security posture in the face of evolving attack vectors. Its integration with other security measures, such as advanced threat detection and data loss prevention, creates a synergistic defense against increasingly sophisticated attacks, safeguarding sensitive data and ensuring business continuity.
7. Security Awareness Training
Security awareness training forms a critical human element within targeted threat protection strategies, complementing technological solutions provided by platforms like Mimecast. While technical defenses offer crucial protection layers, employee vigilance remains essential in identifying and mitigating sophisticated social engineering attacks, such as phishing and impersonation attempts, that often bypass automated filters. A well-trained workforce acts as a robust last line of defense, recognizing and reporting suspicious activity that could otherwise compromise organizational security. This proactive human element significantly strengthens overall defense against targeted threats.
-
Recognizing Phishing Attempts
Training equips employees to identify common indicators of phishing emails, such as suspicious sender addresses, generic greetings, urgent or threatening language, requests for sensitive information, and grammatical errors. Real-world examples, like emails mimicking bank notifications or requests from supposed IT support, help employees discern legitimate communications from fraudulent attempts. This ability to recognize phishing attempts is crucial for preventing credential theft, malware infections, and subsequent data breaches, thereby enhancing the effectiveness of automated email security solutions.
-
Understanding Social Engineering Tactics
Training programs educate employees about various social engineering techniques employed by attackers, including pretexting, baiting, quid pro quo, and tailgating. Understanding these tactics allows employees to recognize manipulative behaviors and avoid falling victim to deceptive requests. For instance, recognizing a pretexting attempt, where an attacker impersonates a colleague to gain access to sensitive information, empowers employees to verify requests through established communication channels, thus strengthening the overall security posture.
-
Safeguarding Sensitive Data
Security awareness training emphasizes the importance of protecting sensitive data, including passwords, financial information, and customer data. Employees learn about best practices for password management, data handling, and reporting potential security incidents. This knowledge reinforces data loss prevention measures implemented within platforms like Mimecast, creating a synergistic defense against both internal and external threats. For example, understanding the risks associated with sharing sensitive data via email encourages employees to utilize secure file-sharing platforms, minimizing the risk of data breaches.
-
Promoting a Security-Conscious Culture
Regular security awareness training fosters a security-conscious culture within the organization, empowering employees to proactively identify and report potential threats. This proactive approach transforms employees from potential vulnerabilities into valuable assets in the fight against targeted attacks. By creating a culture where security is everyone’s responsibility, organizations strengthen their overall defense and reduce the likelihood of successful breaches. This proactive approach enhances the effectiveness of technical solutions by creating a human firewall against sophisticated social engineering attacks.
By fostering a culture of security awareness and empowering employees to actively participate in threat prevention, organizations significantly enhance the effectiveness of technical solutions like Mimecast. This combined approach creates a multi-layered defense, mitigating the risk of targeted attacks and safeguarding sensitive data. Continuous reinforcement of security awareness principles through regular training and simulated phishing exercises ensures that employees remain vigilant and prepared to counter evolving threats, bolstering the overall security posture.
8. Threat Intelligence Feeds
Threat intelligence feeds provide crucial external context, enriching the effectiveness of targeted threat protection platforms. These feeds deliver real-time updates on emerging threats, attacker tactics, and malicious infrastructure, empowering security systems to proactively identify and neutralize potential attacks before they compromise an organization. Integrating threat intelligence feeds into a platform like Mimecast significantly enhances its ability to detect and respond to evolving threats, bolstering overall security posture.
-
Real-time Threat Identification
Threat intelligence feeds provide up-to-the-minute information on newly discovered malware, phishing campaigns, exploit attempts, and other malicious activities. This real-time data empowers security systems to identify and block threats proactively, even before they are widely known. For instance, an intelligence feed might alert a system to a new phishing campaign targeting a specific industry, allowing the platform to immediately enhance scrutiny of emails containing related keywords or originating from suspicious IP addresses, thereby preventing successful attacks.
-
Enhanced Detection Accuracy
By incorporating data from diverse sources, threat intelligence feeds enhance the accuracy of threat detection. These feeds provide context that helps distinguish malicious activity from legitimate communications, reducing false positives and improving overall system effectiveness. For example, an email from a newly registered domain might be flagged as suspicious by traditional security filters. However, threat intelligence could reveal that this domain is associated with a legitimate marketing campaign, allowing the email to be delivered without disruption. This context-rich analysis improves detection accuracy and minimizes disruptions to legitimate business communications.
-
Proactive Vulnerability Management
Threat intelligence feeds often include information on newly discovered software vulnerabilities and exploit attempts. This information allows organizations to proactively patch vulnerable systems and implement appropriate security measures before they are targeted by attackers. For instance, if a zero-day vulnerability in a widely used software application is discovered, threat intelligence can alert security teams to the potential risk, enabling them to deploy patches or implement mitigation strategies before attackers can exploit the vulnerability via malicious email attachments or links.
-
Improved Incident Response
Threat intelligence feeds contribute to more efficient and effective incident response. By providing detailed information about attacker tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs), these feeds assist security teams in understanding the nature and scope of an attack, enabling them to implement appropriate containment and remediation measures quickly. For example, if a phishing attack is detected, threat intelligence can provide insights into the attacker’s methods and potential targets, enabling security teams to identify compromised accounts, contain the spread of malware, and implement preventative measures to protect against similar attacks in the future.
Integrating threat intelligence feeds into a targeted threat protection platform significantly enhances its ability to proactively identify, analyze, and respond to sophisticated email threats. By correlating internal email data with external threat intelligence, the platform gains a more comprehensive view of the threat landscape, empowering it to make more informed decisions about email security and strengthen the overall defense against targeted attacks. This proactive, intelligence-driven approach is crucial for maintaining a robust security posture in today’s dynamic threat environment.
Frequently Asked Questions
This section addresses common inquiries regarding advanced email security solutions and their role in protecting organizations from targeted threats.
Question 1: How does an advanced email security solution differ from basic antivirus and spam filtering?
Advanced solutions go beyond basic filtering by incorporating sophisticated techniques like machine learning, behavioral analysis, and sandboxing to detect and neutralize advanced threats such as zero-day exploits, phishing attacks, and impersonation attempts that often bypass traditional defenses.
Question 2: What is the importance of real-time threat intelligence in email security?
Real-time threat intelligence provides up-to-the-minute information on emerging threats, enabling security systems to proactively identify and block malicious emails based on the latest attack patterns and indicators of compromise.
Question 3: How can organizations defend against increasingly sophisticated phishing and impersonation attacks?
Robust email security solutions employ advanced techniques such as sender authentication, domain reputation analysis, and machine learning to identify and flag potentially fraudulent emails, protecting organizations from impersonation attempts and phishing attacks.
Question 4: What role does data loss prevention play in targeted threat protection?
Data loss prevention (DLP) mechanisms within email security solutions prevent sensitive data, such as financial records or intellectual property, from leaving the organization via email, mitigating the risk of data breaches and regulatory non-compliance.
Question 5: What are the benefits of automated threat remediation in email security?
Automated remediation enables rapid response to identified threats, minimizing potential damage and reducing the burden on security teams. Automated actions, such as quarantining malicious emails or blocking suspicious attachments, enhance efficiency and strengthen overall security posture.
Question 6: How does security awareness training complement technological email security solutions?
Security awareness training educates employees about common threats and best practices for email security, empowering them to identify and report suspicious emails, thereby strengthening the human element of defense against targeted attacks.
Investing in comprehensive email security, including advanced threat detection, data loss prevention, and user awareness training, is crucial for protecting organizations from the evolving threat landscape.
For a deeper understanding of specific features and functionalities within leading email security platforms, consult platform-specific documentation and resources.
Enhancing Email Security
Implementing robust email security requires a multi-faceted approach. The following practical tips provide actionable guidance for strengthening defenses against targeted threats.
Tip 1: Employ Strong Email Authentication Protocols. Implement SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to verify sender identity and prevent email spoofing, a common tactic used in phishing attacks. This helps ensure that emails genuinely originate from the purported sender, reducing the risk of impersonation and fraudulent communications.
Tip 2: Enforce Robust Password Policies. Mandate strong, unique passwords for all email accounts and enforce regular password changes. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) adds an extra layer of security, requiring users to verify their identity through multiple channels, making it significantly more difficult for attackers to gain unauthorized access, even if passwords are compromised.
Tip 3: Regularly Update Email Security Software and Systems. Ensure email security software, including spam filters, antivirus programs, and other security tools, are updated with the latest security patches and threat definitions. Regular updates protect against newly discovered vulnerabilities and emerging threats, maintaining a strong security posture against evolving attack vectors.
Tip 4: Conduct Regular Security Awareness Training. Educate employees about common phishing techniques, social engineering tactics, and best practices for email security. Simulated phishing exercises provide practical experience in identifying and reporting suspicious emails, reinforcing training and strengthening the human element of defense. Training should cover topics such as recognizing suspicious links, attachments, and sender addresses, as well as reporting procedures for suspected phishing attempts.
Tip 5: Implement Robust Data Loss Prevention (DLP) Measures. Configure DLP policies to prevent sensitive data, such as financial records or customer information, from leaving the organization via email. These policies should include content inspection, contextual analysis, and automated remediation actions to prevent data exfiltration. For example, a policy might block emails containing credit card numbers or social security numbers from being sent to external email addresses.
Tip 6: Leverage Threat Intelligence Feeds. Integrate threat intelligence feeds into email security systems to gain real-time insights into emerging threats and attacker tactics. This information enables proactive identification and blocking of malicious emails based on the latest threat data, strengthening defenses against evolving attack vectors. Threat intelligence can provide information on malicious IP addresses, domains, and URLs associated with phishing campaigns and malware distribution.
Tip 7: Regularly Review and Update Email Security Policies. Periodically review and update email security policies to ensure alignment with evolving threats and organizational needs. This ongoing assessment helps maintain a robust security posture and addresses emerging risks. Regular reviews should include an analysis of email traffic patterns, reported security incidents, and changes in the threat landscape to identify areas for improvement and policy adjustments.
By consistently implementing these practical tips, organizations can significantly enhance their email security posture and mitigate the risks associated with targeted threats. These proactive measures strengthen defenses against evolving attack vectors, protecting sensitive data and maintaining business continuity.
The subsequent conclusion will summarize the key takeaways and emphasize the ongoing importance of robust email security in today’s threat landscape.
Conclusion
Organizations face an ever-evolving landscape of sophisticated email threats. Targeted threat protection, encompassing advanced security measures, represents a critical defense against these risks. This exploration has highlighted essential components of a robust email security strategy, including advanced threat detection techniques like machine learning and sandboxing, data loss prevention mechanisms, and the crucial role of user awareness training. Furthermore, the dynamic nature of modern threats necessitates adaptive security policies, automated threat remediation, and the integration of real-time threat intelligence feeds for continuous protection.
Effective email security is not a static destination but an ongoing journey. Maintaining a strong security posture requires continuous vigilance, adaptation, and investment in robust solutions. The evolving sophistication of email-borne threats necessitates a proactive and comprehensive approach, combining advanced technologies with a security-conscious culture, to safeguard sensitive data and ensure business continuity in the face of persistent and evolving risks.
